In the House of Lords, between John Bellenden Ker, Henry Gawler and John Seton Karr, Esquires, appellants and Sir James Norcliffe Innes, baronet and James Horne, his commissioner and Brigadier General Walter Ker, and Richard Hotchkis his mandatory respondents and between Brigadier General Walter Ker and Richard Hotchkis, appellants and Sir James Norcliffe Innes, and James Horne, and John Bellenden Ker, Henry Gawler, and John Seton Karr, Esquires respondents [electronic resource] : case of Sir James Norcliffe Innes, baronet and his commissioner respondents in both appeals.